Graco All-in-One Car Seat Comparison: Features, Pros & Cons

Every Graco All-in-One Car Seat Explained

Graco has a LOT of All-in-One car seats, 14 of them to be exact, and if you’re trying to figure out the differences between all the 4Ever models, Extend2Fit models, SlimFit models, TriRide, Turn2Me, or any other Graco All-in-One, you’re in the right place! We created this guide to help you understand the pros, cons and features of each of these seats.

Most Graco seats are relatively easy to install and use, but with so many options, sorting through them can be a major time suck. You may be tempted to just ask AI to summarize their differences, but we’ve got something better to offer you: trustworthy information from CPST-Instructors who are actual humans with decades of experience!

We've worked with every car seat on this list, so you're getting real-world insights from Kecia and Heather—not AI-generated product descriptions or recycled spec sheets. In this article, we'll walk you through the advantages and disadvantages of each Graco All-in-One Car Seat, share our firsthand observations, and help you narrow down the seats that best meet your needs and budget.

Graco 4Ever DLX 4-in-1

  • Rear-facing: 4-40 lbs., 49” or less, head 1” below handle

  • Forward-facing: 26.5-65 lbs., 49” or less

  • Highback booster: 40-100 lbs., 43-57”, 4+ years old

  • Backless booster: 40-120 lbs., 43-57”, 4+ years old

  • Top harness height: 18”

  • Max shoulder belt height for highback booster: 19 ½”

  • Side bolster insert to 40 lbs.: Yes

  • Lockoff(s): Yes, for forward-facing seatbelt installation only

  • LATCH Weight Limits:

    • Rear-Facing: N/A

    • Forward-Facing: 45 lbs. (When child exceeds 45 lbs, must install with seatbelt + tether)

  • 6 Recline Positions

    • Rear-Facing: Use position 1, 2, or 3 to achieve the proper recline angle in your vehicle based on the angle indicator

    • Forward-Facing: Use position 4 or 5 for kids 26.5-40 lbs. Kids over 40 lbs. must use the fully upright position 6

    • Booster: Must use position 6

  • 10-Year Expiration

  • MSRP $319

  • BLACK FRIDAY DEAL $255 (20% Off)

Pros: The no-rethread harness easily adjusts as your child grows. The harness straps are easy to tighten and loosen. The 4Ever DLX is relatively simple to install in most vehicles and features push-on LATCH connectors. No LATCH weight limit for rear-facing (RF); you can install with lower LATCH anchors the entire time your child is RF. When forward-facing (FF), this seat should work well with most vehicle head restraints. There is a FF lockoff (hidden under the cover) for seatbelt installations. The Rapid Remove cover makes it easy to take off pieces of the cover for washing

Cons: Moving the LATCH strap from RF to FF is confusing, but we have a quick video to guide you. The 4Ever DLX requires standard LATCH spacing of 11” when installing with lower LATCH anchors. This means “borrowing” lower anchors to install the car seat in a center seating position with anchor spacing wider than 11” is not allowed. There is no lockoff for the RF beltpath; if installing RF with seatbelt, you must lock the seatbelt at the retractor. The FF beltpath does have a lockoff for seatbelt installation, but it’s a basic clamp style, not a tensioning “SnugLock” lockoff. The 4Ever DLX is not very tall as a highback booster, and it’s awkward as a backless booster. But don’t let that influence your buying decision right now. You can buy a less awkward, inexpensive backless booster for your big kid in 7 or 8 years.

Comments: The 4Ever DLX is a tried-and-true car seat, but it’s wide and likely won’t fit next to another car seat unless you’re driving a large SUV or a full-size pickup.

There are 6 recline positions, but you are limited in which positions you can actually use. RF recline positions are dictated by the angle indicator, and FF positions by the child’s weight.

The stiff side bolster inserts (which are separate from the infant insert) are required until the child weighs 40 lbs. This means the entire time the child is RF, you’re required to use the side bolsters. And you must continue to use them when FF if the child weighs less than 40 lbs. For some kids with sensory issues, the stiff bolsters could be an issue.

Check out our full review: thecarseatpros.com/blog/graco4everdlxreview

Graco 4Ever DLX 4-in-1 Slim

  • Rear-facing: 4-40 lbs., 49” or less, head 1” below handle

  • Forward-facing: 26.5-65 lbs., 49” or less

  • Highback booster: 40-100 lbs., 43-57”, 4+ years old

  • Backless booster: 40-120 lbs., 43-57”, 4+ years old

  • Top harness height: 19”

  • Shoulder belt height: 20 ½”

  • Side impact bolster insert to 40 lbs.: Yes

  • Lockoff(s): Yes, separate SnugLock tensioning lockoffs for RF & FF

  • LATCH Weight Limits:

    • Rear-Facing: N/A

    • Forward-Facing: 45 lbs. (When child exceeds 45 lbs., must install with seatbelt + tether)

  • 6 Recline Positions

    • Rear-Facing: Use position 1, 2, or 3 to achieve the proper recline angle in your vehicle based on the angle indicator

    • Forward-Facing: Use position 4 or 5 for kids 26.5-40 lbs. Kids over 40 lbs. must use the fully upright position 6

    • Booster: Must use position 6

  • 10-Year Expiration

  • MSRP $369

  • BLACK FRIDAY DEAL $295 (20% Off)

Pros: Dual SnugLock tensioning lockoffs and has the tallest harness height (19”) of any Graco All-in-One car seat! The no-rethread harness adjusts easily as your child grows. The harness straps are easy to tighten and loosen. The 4Ever DLX Slim is very simple to install correctly, thanks to push-on LATCH connectors and SnugLock tensioning lockoffs. No LATCH weight limit for rear-facing (RF); you can install with lower LATCH anchors the entire time your child is RF. When forward-facing (FF), this seat should work well with most vehicle head restraints. The Rapid Remove cover makes it easy to take off pieces of the cover for washing

Cons: Slimmer than the original 4Ever DLX, but not ultra-narrow like the SlimFit3 LX (see details on that seat below). The 4Ever DLX Slim requires standard LATCH spacing of 11” when installing with lower LATCH anchors. This means “borrowing” lower anchors to install the car seat in a center seating position with anchor spacing wider than 11” is not allowed. Luckily, a seatbelt installation is just as quick and easy.

Comments: The 4Ever DLX Slim is our favorite All-in-One Graco car seat! The combination of 19” top harness slots and dual SnugLock lockoffs (one for each beltpath) gives this seat the edge. The tensioning lockoffs provide a simple and secure installation using either LATCH or seat belt (but not both simultaneously). However, just like the original 4Ever DLX, there are 6 recline positions, but you are limited in which positions you can use. RF recline positions are dictated by the angle indicator, and FF positions by the child’s weight. The stiff side bolster inserts, which are separate from the infant insert, are required until the child weighs 40 lbs. For some kids with sensory issues, the hard plastic side bolsters could be an issue.

Graco 4Ever DLX Grad 5-in-1 Slim

  • Rear-facing: 4-40 lbs., 49” or less, head 1” below handle

  • Forward-facing: 26.5-65 lbs., 49” or less

  • Highback booster: 40-100 lbs., 43-57”, 4+ years old

  • Backless booster: 40-120 lbs., 43-57”, 4+ years old

  • Seat belt trainer: 50-120 lbs., 43-60”, 5+ years old

  • Top harness height: 19”

  • Shoulder belt height: 20 ½”

  • Side impact bolster insert to 40 lbs.: Yes

  • Lockoff(s): Yes, separate SnugLock tensioning lockoffs for RF & FF

  • LATCH Weight Limits:

    • Rear-Facing: N/A

    • Forward-Facing: 45 lbs. (When child exceeds 45 lbs, must install with seatbelt + tether)

  • 6 Recline Positions

    • Rear-Facing: Use position 1, 2, or 3 to achieve the proper recline angle in your vehicle based on the angle indicator

    • Forward-Facing: Use recline position 4 or 5 for kids 26.5-40 lbs. Kids over 40 lbs. MUST use the fully upright position 6

    • Booster: Must use the fully upright position 6

  • 10-Year Expiration

  • MSRP $429

  • BLACK FRIDAY DEAL $299 (30% Off)

Pros: Dual SnugLock tensioning lockoffs, tall harness height, and a unique seat belt trainer which acts as a bridge between a traditional backless booster seat and a seatbelt for tweens who only need a little boost for proper belt fit. The no-rethread harness easily adjusts as your child grows. The harness straps are easy to tighten and loosen. The 4Ever Grad is pretty simple to install, thanks to push-on LATCH connectors and SnugLock tensioning lockoffs. No LATCH weight limit for rear-facing (RF); you can install RF with lower LATCH anchors the entire time your child is RF. When forward-facing (FF), this seat should work well with most vehicle head restraints. The Rapid Remove cover makes it easy to take off pieces of the cover for washing.

Cons: Slimmer than the original 4Ever, but not ultra-narrow like the SlimFit3 LX. The seat belt trainer adds another layer, literally, which can increase the chances of misuse. RF installation is more involved since you need to remove the seat belt trainer first before you can access the beltpath with the SnugLock lockoff, and then reattach it after installation since it’s required when the child is RF. Unfortunately, when the seat belt trainer is attached, the buckle/crotch strap is pretty short, which can be an issue for bigger rear-facing children. The 4Ever Grad requires standard LATCH spacing of 11” when installing with lower LATCH anchors. This means “borrowing” lower anchors to install the car seat in a center seating position with anchor spacing wider than 11” is not allowed. Luckily, a seatbelt installation is just as quick and easy.

Comments: The Grad is a 4Ever DLX Slim with the seatbelt trainer. It has everything we love about the 4ever Slim (tall top harness slots and dual SnugLock lockoffs), plus the bonus of the seat belt trainer. This is the longest-lasting Graco All-in-One! The tensioning SnugLock lockoffs provide a simple and secure installation using either LATCH or seat belt (but not both simultaneously). However, just like the 4Ever DLX Slim, there are 6 recline positions, but you are limited in which positions you can use. RF recline positions are dictated by the angle indicator, and FF positions by the child’s weight. The hard plastic side bolsters, which are separate from the infant insert, are required until the child weighs more than 40 lbs. For some kids with sensory issues, the side bolsters could be an issue.

Current 4Ever Grad models require the seat belt trainer to be attached to the seat when it‘s used rear-facing. This limits some of its functionality because you can no longer use the trainer for an older child while a younger child is using the 4Ever Grad RF. However, the seat belt trainer MUST be removed for forward-facing and highback booster use, so that allows flexibility to use the seat belt trainer for a second child, if needed. The seat belt trainer is ideal for tweens who don’t need as much of a boost as a regular backless booster provides.

Graco 4Ever Extend2Fit DLX 4-in-1

  • Rear-facing: 4-50 lbs., 49” or less, head 1” below handle

  • Forward-facing: 26.5-65 lbs., 49” or less

  • Highback booster: 40-100 lbs., 43-57”, 4+ years old

  • Backless booster: 40-120 lbs., 43-57”, 4+ years old

  • Top harness height: 17 ½”

  • Shoulder belt height: 18 ½”

  • Side impact bolster insert to 40 lbs.: Yes

  • Lockoff(s): Yes, for forward-facing seatbelt installation only

  • LATCH Weight Limits:

    • Rear-Facing: 35 lbs. (When child exceeds 35 lbs., must install with seatbelt)

    • Forward-Facing: 40 lbs. (When child exceeds 40 lbs., must install with seatbelt + tether)

  • 6 Recline Positions

    • Rear-Facing: Use position 1, 2, 3 or 4 to achieve the proper recline angle in your vehicle based on the angle indicator

    • Forward-Facing: Use recline position 5 for kids 26.5-40 lbs. Kids over 40 lbs. MUST use the fully upright position 6

    • Booster: Must use the fully upright position 6

  • 10-Year Expiration

  • MSRP $379

  • BLACK FRIDAY DEAL $303 (20% Off)

Pros: A blend of the 4Ever and Extend2Fit models. It has 4 modes of use combined with a 50 lbs. rear-facing (RF) weight limit and 4-position legrest extension panel. The no-rethread harness easily adjusts as your child grows. The harness straps are easy to tighten and loosen. The 4Ever Extend2Fit is relatively simple to install in most vehicles and features push-on LATCH connectors. When forward-facing (FF), this seat should work well with most vehicle head restraints. There is a FF lockoff (hidden under the cover) for seatbelt installations only. Blue sticker labels on the bottom edge of the base help identify how much overhang is allowed when RF.

Cons: Extending the legrest extension panel gives a taller rear-facing child more legroom, but there are tradeoffs. The more you extend the panel, the more front-to-back space the car seat takes up, which can reduce the legroom space for the adult in the front seat. Also, moving the LATCH strap from RF to FF is confusing but we have a quick video to guide you. If installing RF with seatbelt, there is no lockoff, so you must lock the seatbelt at the retractor. FF beltpath does have a lockoff, but it’s a basic clamp style, not a tensioning “SnugLock” lockoff. The 4Ever Extend2Fit requires standard LATCH spacing of 11” when installing with lower LATCH anchors. This means “borrowing” lower anchors to install in a center seating position is not allowed. It’s not very tall as a highback booster, and it’s bulky and awkward as a backless booster.

Comments: Currently, only available on Graco’s website and Babylist. The 4Ever Extend2Fit is a heavy, bulky seat. There are 6 recline positions (4 for RF, 2 for FF), but you are limited in which positions you can use. RF recline positions are dictated by the angle indicator, and FF positions by the child’s weight. The stiff side bolsters, which are separate from the infant insert, are required until the child weighs 40 lbs. For kids with sensory issues, the side bolsters could be an issue.

Graco Extend2Fit 3-in-1

  • Rear-facing: 4-50 lbs., 49” or less, head 1” below handle

  • Forward-facing: 26.5-65 lbs., 49” or less

  • Highback booster: 40-100 lbs., 43-57”, 4+ years old

  • Top harness height: 17 ½”

  • Shoulder belt height: 18 ½”

  • Side impact bolster insert to 40 lbs.: No

  • Lockoff(s): None

  • LATCH Weight Limits:

    • Rear-Facing: 40 lbs. (When child exceeds 40 lbs., must install with seatbelt)

    • Forward-Facing: 45 lbs. (When child exceeds 45 lbs., must install with seatbelt + tether)

  • 6 Recline Positions

    • Rear-Facing: Use position 1, 2, 3, or 4 to achieve the proper recline angle in your vehicle based on the angle indicator

    • Forward-Facing: Use recline position 4, 5, or 6 for kids 26.5-40 lbs. Kids over 40 lbs. MUST use the fully upright position 6

    • Booster: Must use the fully upright position 6

  • 10-Year Expiration

  • MSRP $269

Pros: 50 lbs. rear-facing (RF) weight limit and 4-position legrest extension panel at a great price makes the Extend2Fit 3-in-1 our top pick for extended rear-facing. Blue sticker label on the bottom edge of the base helps to identify how much overhang is allowed when RF. The no-rethread harness easily adjusts height as your child grows. The harness is easy to tighten and loosen. No side bolster inserts. The Extend2Fit is relatively easy to install in most vehicles and features push-on LATCH connectors. When forward-facing (FF), this seat should work well with most vehicle head restraints.

Cons: Extending the legrest extension panel gives taller rear-facing kids more legroom, but there is a tradeoff. The more you extend the panel, the more front-to-back space the car seat takes up, which can reduce the legroom space for the adult in the front seat and/or make the bottom of the car seat overhang the vehicle seat cushion too much. Also, moving the LATCH strap from RF to FF is confusing, but we have a quick video to guide you. If installing with seatbelt (RF or FF), there are no lockoffs, so you must lock the seatbelt at the retractor. The Extend2Fit 3-in-1 requires standard LATCH spacing of 11” when installing with lower LATCH anchors. This means “borrowing” lower anchors to install in a center seating position that has lower anchor spacing wider than 11” is not allowed. It’s not very tall as a highback booster, so don’t expect it to be the last seat your child ever needs. But don’t let that influence your buying decision right now. You can buy an inexpensive backless booster for your big kid in 7 or 8 years.

Comments: Extend2Fit is wide and likely won’t fit next to another car seat unless you’re driving a large SUV or a full-size pickup. Also, don’t confuse this 3-in-1 model with the Graco Extend2Fit 2-in-1, which isn’t on this list because it isn’t an “all-in-one” car seat. Parents and caregivers looking to purchase an Extend2Fit model should skip the 2-in-1 model, which can’t be used as a booster. It’s not just the lack of a booster feature; there are several other reasons that we don’t prefer the Extend2Fit 2-in-1 convertible seat. To be fair, it’s not awful, but for a few bucks more, the Extend2Fit 3-in-1 is a better car seat overall.

Graco Extend2Fit 3-in-1 with Anti-Rebound Bar

  • Rear-facing: 4-50 lbs., 49” or less, head 1” below handle

  • Forward-facing: 26.5-65 lbs., 49” or less

  • Highback booster: 40-100 lbs., 43-57”, 4+ years old

  • Top harness height: 17 ½”

  • Shoulder belt height: 18 ½”

  • Side impact bolster insert to 40 lbs.: No

  • Lockoff(s): None

  • LATCH Weight Limits:

    • Rear-Facing: 40 lbs. (When child exceeds 40 lbs., must install with seatbelt)

    • Forward-Facing: 45 lbs. (When child exceeds 45 lbs., must install with seatbelt + tether)

  • 6 Recline Positions

    • Rear-Facing: Use position 1, 2, 3, or 4 to achieve the proper recline angle in your vehicle based on the angle indicator

    • Forward-Facing: Use recline position 4, 5, or 6 for kids 26.5-40 lbs. Kids over 40 lbs. MUST use the fully upright position 6

    • Booster: Must use fully upright position 6

  • 10-Year Expiration

  • MSRP $339

Pros: 50 lbs. rear-facing weight limit, 4-position legrest extension panel and anti-rebound bar (ARB). Blue sticker label on the bottom edge of the base helps to identify how much overhang is allowed when RF. The no-rethread harness easily adjusts height as your child grows. The harness adjustment is smooth and easy to tighten and loosen. No side bolster inserts. The Extend2Fit with ARB is relatively easy to install in most vehicles and features push-on LATCH connectors. When forward-facing (FF), this seat should work well with most vehicle head restraints. RapidRemove cover makes it easy to take off pieces for washing.

Cons: The ARB attaches to the legrest extension panel and typically makes the seat take up a bit more room front-to-back. Extending the legrest extension panel gives a taller rear-facing child more legroom, but there is a tradeoff. The more you extend the panel, the more front-to-back space the car seat takes up, which can reduce the legroom space for the adult in the front seat. Also, moving the LATCH strap from RF to FF is confusing if you don’t understand the process, but we have a quick video to guide you. If installing with seatbelt (RF or FF), there are no lockoffs, so you must lock the seatbelt at the retractor. The Extend2Fit with ARB requires standard LATCH spacing of 11” when installing with lower LATCH anchors. This means “borrowing” lower anchors to install in a center seating position with anchor spacing greater than 11” is not allowed. It’s not very tall as a highback booster, so don’t expect it to be the last seat your child ever needs.

Comments: Available from the Graco website and sometimes from wholesale clubs like Sam’s or BJ’s. This seat is similar to the Extend2Fit 3-in-1 model but with the addition of the anti-rebound bar (ARB). The ARB combined with the legrest extension panel may create confusion for parents or caregivers who aren’t familiar with how and when to use these features. Also, the addition of the ARB may change how the car seat fits on the vehicle seat. In some vehicles, the ARB will not make contact with the back of the vehicle seat. In other vehicles, the ARB may push the car seat forward a bit. This isn’t an ideal car seat for rookies.

Graco Grows4Me 4-in-1

  • Rear-facing: 5-40 lbs., 49” or less, head 1” below handle

  • Forward-facing: 26.5-65 lbs., 49” or less

  • Highback booster: 40-100 lbs., 43-57”, 4+ years old

  • Backless booster: 40-110 lbs., 43-57”, 4+ years old

  • Top harness height: 18”

  • Shoulder belt height: 19”

  • Side impact bolster insert to 40 lbs.: No

  • Lockoff(s): None

  • LATCH Weight Limits:

    • Rear-Facing: N/A

    • Forward-Facing: 45 lbs. (When child exceeds 45 lbs, must install with seatbelt + tether)

  • 6 Recline Positions

    • Rear-Facing: Use position 1, 2, or 3 to achieve the proper recline angle in your vehicle based on the angle indicator

    • Forward-Facing: Use recline position 4 or 5 for kids 26.5-40 lbs. Kids over 40 lbs. MUST use the fully upright position 6

    • Booster: Must use fully upright position 6

  • 10-Year Expiration

  • MSRP $229

Pros: The no-rethread harness easily adjusts height as your child grows. The harness is easy to tighten and loosen. No side bolster inserts. The Grows4Me is relatively easy to install in most vehicles. No LATCH weight limit for rear-facing (RF), which means you can install RF with lower LATCH anchors up to the max child weight limit of 40 lbs. When forward-facing (FF), this seat should work well with most vehicle head restraints.

Cons: Basic hook-style LATCH connectors. Moving the LATCH strap from RF to FF is confusing if you don’t understand the process, but we have a quick video to guide you. If installing with seatbelt (RF or FF), there are no lockoffs, so you must lock the seatbelt at the retractor. The Grows4Me is not very tall as a highback booster, and it’s awkward as a backless booster. But don’t let that influence your buying decision right now. You can buy a less awkward, inexpensive backless booster for your big kid in 7 or 8 years.

Comments: It’s a scaled-back version of the 4Ever with no lockoffs, a basic cover, and just a single cup holder. Grows4Me is a wide seat and likely won’t fit next to another car seat unless you’re driving a large SUV or a full-size pickup. Also, there are 6 recline positions, but you are limited in which positions you can use. RF recline positions are dictated by the angle indicator, and FF positions by the child’s weight.

Graco SlimFit 3-in-1

  • Rear-facing: 5-40 lbs., 49” or less, head 1” below handle

  • Forward-facing: 26.5-65 lbs., 49” or less

  • Highback booster: 40-100 lbs., 43-57”, 4+ years old

  • Top harness height: 18”

  • Shoulder belt height: 19 ½”

  • Side impact bolster insert to 40 lbs.: No

  • Lockoff(s): None

  • LATCH Weight Limits:

    • Rear-Facing: N/A

    • Forward-Facing: 45 lbs. (When child exceeds 45 lbs, must install with seatbelt + tether)

  • 4 Recline Positions

    • Rear-Facing: Use position 1 or 2 to achieve the proper recline angle in your vehicle based on the angle indicator

    • Forward-Facing: You can use recline positions 3 or 4 without any restrictions based on child’s weight.

    • Booster: Must use fully upright position 4

  • 10-Year Expiration

  • MSRP $229

Pros: The no-rethread harness easily adjusts the height as your child grows. The harness straps are easy to tighten and loosen. The SlimFit is easy to install in most vehicles and features push-on LATCH connectors. No LATCH weight limit for rear-facing (RF); you can install with lower LATCH anchors up to the max RF weight limit of 40 lbs. When forward-facing (FF), this seat should work well with most vehicle head restraints. The dual cupholders are designed to swivel and can take up a little less space, if needed. The cover removes in pieces for ease of cleaning.

Cons: Now that Graco has an ultra-narrow car seat with a similar name, it’s easy to confuse the different models, which are all called “SlimFit”. This is the original SlimFit 3-in-1, which is 18.5” wide. This is NOT the ultra-narrow SlimFit3 LX, which is only 16.7” wide.

Moving the LATCH strap from RF to FF is confusing, but we have a quick video to guide you. If installing with seatbelt (RF or FF), there are no lockoffs, so you must lock the seatbelt at the retractor. The SlimFit 3-in-1 requires standard LATCH spacing of 11” when installing with lower LATCH anchors. This means “borrowing” lower anchors to install in a center seating position that has lower anchor spacing wider than 11” is not allowed. It’s not very tall as a highback booster, so don’t expect it to be the last seat your child ever needs. But don’t let that influence your buying decision right now. You can buy an inexpensive backless booster for your big kid in 7 or 8 years.

Comments: The original Graco SlimFit model is a tried-and-true car seat that we frequently recommend. If you catch it on sale for under $200, it’s a fantastic deal. It’s a little slimmer than the 4Ever & Extend2Fit models but not as slim as the SlimFit3 LX. This model doesn’t have side bolster inserts or rules about which recline position you need to use based on the child’s weight. It’s straightforward and easy to use correctly. This is a solid, comfortable seat that works well in all 3 modes (RF, FF & Booster). It’s just not ultra-narrow like that other Graco seat with a similar name.

Check out our detailed comparison of the various SlimFit models: thecarseatpros.com/blog/slimfits

Graco SlimFit LX 3-in-1

All the same specs, pros, and cons as the original SlimFit 3-in-1 above.

Comments: Don’t confuse this SlimFit LX model with the ultra-narrow SlimFit3 LX model (Seriously, Graco?). This is just another version of the original SlimFit model with a slightly different cover. This is also the seat that makes us shake our fists at the Graco marketing team that names these products. This model features a Rapid Remove cover and a little storage pouch. It’s the same price as the regular SlimFit, but it’s only available at Walmart and from the Graco website.If you catch it on sale for under $200, it’s a great deal.

Check out our detailed comparison of all the SlimFit models: thecarseatpros.com/blog/slimfits

Graco SlimFit3 LX 3-in-1

  • Rear-facing: 5-40 lbs., 49” or less, head 1” below handle

  • Forward-facing: 26.5-65 lbs., 49” or less

  • Highback booster: 40-100 lbs., 43-57”, 4+ years old

  • Top harness height: 17 ½ ”

  • Shoulder belt height: 19 ½”

  • Side impact bolster insert to 40 lbs.: No

  • Lockoff(s): Yes, for forward-facing seatbelt installation only

  • LATCH Weight Limits:

    • Rear-Facing: N/A

    • Forward-Facing: 45 lbs. (When child exceeds 45 lbs, must install with seatbelt + tether)

  • 4 Recline Positions

    • Rear-Facing: Use position 1 or 2 to achieve the proper recline angle in your vehicle based on the angle indicator

    • Forward-Facing: You can use recline positions 3 or 4 without any restrictions based on child’s weight.

    • Booster: Must use fully upright position 4

  • 10-Year Expiration

  • MSRP $299

Pros: At 16.7” wide, this is the narrowest Graco car seat, which is great if you’re trying to fit 3-across. The no-rethread harness easily adjusts as your child grows. The harness straps are easy to tighten and loosen. The SlimFit3 LX is relatively easy to install in most vehicles and features push-on LATCH connectors. No LATCH weight limit for rear-facing (RF), which means you can install RF with lower LATCH anchors up to the max child weight limit of 40 lbs. When forward-facing (FF), this seat should work well with most vehicle head restraints. There is a FF lockoff (hidden under the cover) for seatbelt installations. The Rapid Remove cover makes it easy to take off pieces of the cover for washing.

Cons: If installing RF with seatbelt, there is no lockoff, so you must lock the seatbelt at the retractor. The seat can sometimes be tippy when installing RF with the seatbelt, but installing with lower LATCH anchors instead, if possible, will solve that issue. FF beltpath does have a lockoff, but it’s a basic clamp style, not a tensioning “SnugLock” lockoff. The SlimFit3 LX requires standard LATCH spacing of 11” when installing with lower LATCH anchors. This means “borrowing” lower anchors to install in a center seating position is not allowed. It’s not very tall as a highback booster, and older kids may look and feel cramped, especially if they have a stocky build or broad shoulders. But don’t let that influence your buying decision right now. If you need an ultra-narrow seat right now, that’s the priority.

Comments: More upright than other Graco seats when rear-facing, which could be a pro or con depending on the child’s age, developmental level, and overall comfort. This model doesn’t have side bolster inserts or rules about which recline position you need to use based on the child’s weight. It’s pretty straightforward and generally easy to use correctly. Just be careful and make sure you’re buying the SlimFit model you intended to purchase. Currently, there are only 2 fashions available for the SlimFit3 LX - Kunningham 2.0 and Katrina 2.0.

We’re so happy that this model exists, but if you don’t need an ultra-narrow car seat, you may be better off in the long run with something a little roomier, like the original SlimFit. Check out our detailed comparison of the various SlimFit models: thecarseatpros.com/blog/slimfits

Graco TrioGrow SnugLock 3-in-1

  • Rear-facing: 5-40 lbs., 49” or less, head 1” below handle

  • Forward-facing: 26.5-65 lbs., 49” or less

  • Highback booster: 40-100 lbs., 43-57”, 4+ years old

  • Top harness height: 18”

  • Shoulder belt height: 19”

  • Side impact bolster insert to 40 lbs.: No

  • Lockoff(s): One swiveling SnugLock tensioning lockoff that can be used RF or FF

  • LATCH Weight Limits:

    • Rear-Facing: N/A

    • Forward-Facing: 45 lbs. (When child exceeds 45 lbs, must install with seatbelt + tether)

  • 6 Recline Positions

    • Rear-Facing: Use position 1, 2, or 3 to achieve the proper recline angle in your vehicle based on the angle indicator

    • Forward-Facing: Use recline position 4, 5 or 6 for kids 26.5-40 lbs. Kids over 40 lbs. MUST use recline position 5.

    • Booster: Must use fully upright position 6

  • 10-Year Expiration

  • MSRP $199

Pros: One SnugLock belt-tensioning lockoff that rotates between rear- and forward-facing belt paths. The no-rethread harness easily adjusts the height as your child grows. No side bolster inserts. The TrioGrow is easy to install in most vehicles. No LATCH weight limit for rear-facing (RF), which means you can install RF with lower LATCH anchors up to the max child weight limit. When forward-facing (FF), this seat should work well with most vehicle head restraints.

Cons: Basic, hook-style LATCH connectors. A single red level line on a sticker does not allow for a range of recline angles when rear-facing and makes it more difficult to achieve the necessary angle in a variety of vehicles. The harness straps can be difficult to tighten and loosen compared with most other Graco All-in-One seats.

Comments: The tensioning SnugLock lockoff provides a secure installation using either LATCH or seat belt (but not both simultaneously). There are 6 recline positions, but you are limited in which positions you can use. RF recline positions are dictated by the single level-to-ground line, and FF positions are dictated by the child’s weight.

The TrioGrow is a Walmart exclusive.

Graco TriRide 3-in-1

  • Rear-facing: 5-40 lbs., 49” or less, head 1” below handle

  • Forward-facing: 26.5-65 lbs., 49” or less

  • Highback booster: 40-100 lbs., 43-57”, 4+ years old

  • Top harness height: 18”

  • Shoulder belt height: 19”

  • Side impact bolster insert to 40 lbs.: No

  • Lockoff(s): None

  • LATCH Weight Limits:

    • Rear-Facing: N/A

    • Forward-Facing: 45 lbs. (When child exceeds 45 lbs, must install with seatbelt + tether)

  • 6 Recline Positions

    • Rear-Facing: Use position 1, 2, or 3 to achieve the proper recline angle in your vehicle based on the angle indicator

    • Forward-Facing: Use recline position 4, 5 or 6 for kids 26.5-40 lbs. Kids over 40 lbs. MUST use recline position 5.

    • Booster: Must use fully upright position 6

  • 10-Year Expiration

  • MSRP $199

Pros: The no-rethread harness easily adjusts as your child grows. No side bolster inserts. The TriRide is relatively easy to install in most vehicles. No LATCH weight limit for rear-facing (RF); you can install RF with lower LATCH anchors up to the max child weight limit of 40 lbs. When forward-facing (FF), this seat should work well with most vehicle head restraints.

Cons: Basic, hook-style LATCH connectors. A single red level line on a sticker does not allow for a range of recline angles when rear-facing and makes it more difficult to achieve the necessary angle in a variety of vehicles. The harness straps can be difficult to tighten and loosen compared with most other Graco All-in-One seats.

Comments: The TriRide is Graco’s base model All-in-One. It’s a TrioGrow minus the SnugLock lockoff. There are 6 recline positions, but you are limited in which positions you can use. RF recline positions are dictated by the single level-to-ground line, and FF positions by the child’s weight.

Graco True3Fit LX 3-in-1

  • Rear-facing: 5-40 lbs., 49” or less, head 1” below handle

  • Forward-facing: 26.5-65 lbs., 49” or less

  • Highback booster: 40-100 lbs., 43-57”, 4+ years old

  • Top harness height: 17 ½”

  • Shoulder belt height: 19 ½”

  • Side impact bolster insert to 40 lbs.: No

  • Lockoff(s): Yes, for forward-facing seatbelt installation only

  • LATCH Weight Limits:

    • Rear-Facing: N/A

    • Forward-Facing: 45 lbs. (When child exceeds 45 lbs, must install with seatbelt + tether)

  • 4 Recline Positions

    • Rear-Facing: Use position 1 or 2 to achieve the proper recline angle in your vehicle based on the angle indicator

    • Forward-Facing: You can use recline positions 3 or 4 without any restrictions based on child’s weight.

    • Booster: Must use fully upright position 4

  • 10-Year Expiration

  • MSRP $284

Pros: Narrowest Graco car seat with an anti-rebound bar. This is a great option if you’re trying to fit 3-across. The no-rethread harness easily adjusts as your child grows. The harness straps are easy to tighten and loosen. The True3Fit LX is relatively easy to install in most vehicles and features push-on LATCH connectors. No LATCH weight limit for rear-facing (RF); you can install RF with lower LATCH anchors up to the max child weight limit. When forward-facing (FF), this seat should work well with most vehicle head restraints. There is a FF lockoff (hidden under the cover) for seatbelt installations.

Cons: No cup holders because the ARB uses the same attachment points that would otherwise be used to secure the cup holders. If installing RF with seatbelt, there is no lockoff, so you need to lock the seatbelt at the retractor. The seat can sometimes be tippy when installing RF with the seat belt, but installing with lower anchors instead, if possible, will solve that issue. FF beltpath does have a lockoff, but it’s a basic clamp style, not a tensioning “SnugLock” lockoff. The True3Fit LX requires standard LATCH spacing of 11” when installing with lower LATCH anchors. This means “borrowing” lower anchors to install in a center seating position with anchors spaced more than 11” apart is not allowed. It’s not very tall as a highback booster, and older kids may look and feel cramped, especially if they have a stocky build or broad shoulders.

Comments: Clone of the SlimFit3 LX with the addition of an ARB. Just like the SlimFit3 LX, the True3Fit tends to install more upright when rear-facing, which could be a pro or con depending on the child’s age, developmental level, and overall comfort. This model doesn’t have side bolster inserts or rules about which recline position to use based on the child’s weight. It’s pretty straightforward and generally easy to use correctly.

Graco Turn2Me 3-in-1

  • Rear-facing: 5-40 lbs., 49” or less, head 1” below handle

  • Forward-facing: 26.5-65 lbs., 49” or less

  • Highback booster: 40-100 lbs., 43-57”, 4+ years old

  • Top harness height: 17″

  • Shoulder belt height: 18 ½”

  • Side impact bolster insert to 40 lbs.: No

  • Lockoff(s): Yes, separate SnugLock tensioning lockoffs for RF & FF

  • LATCH Weight Limits:

    • Rear-Facing: 35 lbs. (When child exceeds 35 lbs., must install with seatbelt)

    • Forward-Facing: 40 lbs. (When child exceeds 40 lbs., must install with seatbelt + tether)

  • 4 Recline Positions

    • Rear-Facing: Use position 1, 2, 3, or 4 to achieve the proper recline angle in your vehicle based on the angle indicator

    • Forward-Facing: Use recline position 2 or 3 to achieve the proper recline angle in your vehicle based on the angle indicator

    • Booster: Must use recline position 1

  • 10-Year Expiration

  • MSRP $399

Pros: Turn2Me can swivel to the side for loading/unloading when installed rear-facing. SnugLock belt-tensioning lockoffs in both rear- and forward-facing belt paths. No side bolsters.

Cons: Does not rotate when installed FF. Can be tippy in RF mode when installed with seatbelt, which can cause the seat to loosen on its own, even when properly installed. (See comments)

Comments: This is Graco’s original rotating car seat, and it has some potentially serious issues. Their newest rotating seat, EasyTurn360, is just a convertible (no booster mode). As such, it’s not on this list of Graco All-in-One seats.

The rear-facing belt path on Turn2Me is tight, even for small hands. The RF SnugLock lockoff isn’t as effective as we expected and requires pre-tensioning the seatbelt or latch strap before closing the lockoff. When the seat is installed RF with seatbelt and bigger kids are loaded from the side-facing position, the seat can tip significantly. The tipping allows slack in the shoulder belt portion of the seatbelt to migrate into the lap belt portion, and the installation loosens, even if you’ve locked the seat belt at the retractor. We have more information on the Turn2Me and Graco’s other rotating car seat, EasyTurn 360, in our Rotating Car Seats Comparison article.

Next
Next

The Consumer’s Guide to Car Seat Return Policies